This means that landlords will now be free again to file eviction proceedings against tenants effective September 2, 2020.
Landlords are cautioned, however, that this newly-regained freedom to undertake evictions could be short-lived. Chief Justice Tani G. Cantil-Sakauye, who chairs the Judicial Council, exhibited some degree of uneasiness in having the judicial branch of government issuing emergency rules that address problems that really are more appropriately handled through the legislative process. She urged the legislature and executive branches to “resolve the looming crisis” of the housing market and how it has been impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic. In fact, the California Assembly has already passed legislation to protect tenants suffering financial hardship due to the pandemic from eviction proceedings through at least April 2021 (Bill 1436 authored by David Chiu (D-San Francisco) and Monique Limon (D-Santa Barbara)) and the Senate is expected to act soon on the measure.
In light of the impending legislation, and the small window of time that exists for landlords to take action), it is recommended that landlords move expeditiously to enforce leases through the eviction process before the new legislation can take effect.
If you are a landlord who has been needing to terminate a tenancy through the eviction process, but have been unable to do so due to the temporary emergency rules which have prohibited evictions, please do not hesitate to call The Law Offices of Robert F. French at (530) 587-5500 to consult about your particular tenant matter to see if we can assist you.
]]>While the homeowner was away from her home for an extended time, the paver performed the paving work on the driveway and invoiced the homeowner. Upon receiving the paver’s invoice, the homeowner contacted the paver and complained that she had never agreed with the paver to have him perform the work. Further, upon returning home and inspecting the work, she pointed out to the paver that the work was not performed in a workmanlike manner, nor was it performed according to her expectations which she had discussed with the paver’s representative when provided with the estimate. As a result, she declined to pay the paver’s invoice.
A Lawsuit Is Filed
The paver sued the homeowner claiming that he and the homeowner had reached an agreement that authorized him to perform the work and that he was owed the invoice amount.
At trial, we contended on the homeowner’s behalf that there had never been any agreement actually reached between the parties despite the fact that the paver had proceeded to perform the paving work and, further, that the work had not been performed in a workmanlike manner. We also contended that the paver had violated Business & Professions Code Section 7159 by performing home improvement work without a signed written contract. (Note: All references are to the California Business & Professions Code.)
The Requirement Of A Written Contract
Section 7159 requires that a contractor have a written “home improvement contract”, signed by both parties, for any work of home improvement where the cost of the contractor’s labor, services, and materials will exceed $500.
Section 7151 defines “home improvement” to include “the repairing, remodeling, altering, converting, or modernizing of, or adding to, residential property and shall include, but not be limited to, the construction, erection, replacement, or improvement of driveways, swimming pools, including spas and hot tubs, terraces, patios, awnings, storm windows, landscaping, fences, porches, garages, fallout shelters, basements, and other improvements of the structures or land which is adjacent to a dwelling house.” “Home improvement” also includes the installation of home improvement goods or the furnishing of home improvement services.
The law requires that the written contract contain important disclosures to the homeowner, including the homeowner’s right to cancel the contract within three days, a warning to the homeowner that the contractor may enforce his or her rights to payment with a mechanic’s lien, and notices regarding the contractor’s general liability insurance and worker’s compensation insurance coverages. The contract also must contain a notice to the homeowner regarding how changes to the scope of work of the contract are to be handled, and a notice regarding the homeowner’s right to file a complaint against the contractor with the Contractor’s State License Board.
And, of great importance for the contractor to note, Section 7159.5 makes it a misdemeanor for a home improvement contractor to not have a signed written contract for a home improvement project.
The Written Contract Is Required To Protect The Homeowner
The Legislature adopted Section 7159 to protect homeowners from the abusive actions of unscrupulous contractors in taking advantage of homeowners. Calwood Structures, Inc. v. Herskovic (1980) 105 Cal. App.3d 519, 164 Cal. Rptr. 463. While the horror stories that one typically hears about abusive home improvement contractors seem to deal with swimming pool contractors or siding installation contractors, the scope of the statute is much broader than just these specific trades. It includes any repairs, or remodeling of a residential property.
The Exception To Every Rule
Appellate courts have carved out some limited exceptions to this rule of Section 7159 requiring a written contract, most often in those cases where the homeowner is not within the class of individuals whom the statute is designed to protect. Asdourian v. Araj (1985) 38 Cal.3d 276, 211 Cal.Rptr. 703. The courts have often considered the level of sophistication of the property owner, the scope or complexity of the project, the homeowner’s prior contracting experience, whether someone was assisting the homeowner in the negotiations with the contractor, such as an attorney or architect, the prior relationship between the contractor and owner as friends, and whether the homeowner subsequently ratified the contractor’s work.
The Decision
In our case, the court sided with our homeowner client finding that the paver had failed to comply with Section 7159 because he had failed to use a signed written contract for his home improvement services. The homeowner was not required to pay the paver’s invoice even though the paver had contributed labor, services, and materials to the paving job.
This may seem like a harsh result for the paver, who lost many thousands of dollars in the job, but the policy of Section 7159 is very strong in seeking to protect the homeowner. In adopting the statute, the Legislature concluded that the contractor, as the more sophisticated business person, should be able to easily comply with the requirement of a written contract and that, if he or she failed to use a written contract, then he or she should be the one to bear the financial loss.
Had the paver, at a minimum, have sent the homeowner an email confirming that the work had been authorized and setting forth the basic terms of the agreement (price, time for performance, payment terms, etc.), he would have been in a much better position to argue at trial that he shouldn’t have to bear the financial loss of the project. Nevertheless, the use of a written home improvement contract, containing all of the necessary disclosures required by law, is always the best approach for any contractor performing “home improvement” contracting services.
]]>So, what does the law say should happen to someone who intentionally interferes with our joys of pet ownership by harming or destroying our pet?
In February 2000, in a fit of road rage after having been bumped from the rear in traffic by another driver, Andrew Burnett angrily confronted the other driver and took the driver’s bichon frise dog, Leo, from her lap and hurled it into oncoming traffic on a busy road near the San Jose International Airport, where Leo died. Some nine years later (really? it had to take that long?), Burnett was convicted of felony animal cruelty and was given the maximum sentence available of three years in prison.
But, Burnett’s conviction did nothing to restore Leo to his owner or to ease her intense grief caused by Leo’s death. The dog’s owner had suffered a real emotional loss by Burnett’s conduct and his sentence did nothing to compensate her for it. Which then raises the question — Can a pet owner be compensated in civil monetary damages for the mental suffering experienced when a third party intentionally kills or harms the pet?
Let’s look at the case of Plotnik v. Meihaus (2012) 208 Cal.App.4th 1590 for the answer.
And So The Trouble Begins
The Plotniks and David Meihaus were adjoining property owners in Laguna Niguel, California. When the Plotniks bought their home, there was an existing three-foot fence on the property line. But, after experiencing problems with Meihaus, the Plotniks built a new six-foot fence to provide them greater insulation against those problems. Meihaus, however, sued the Plotniks and their homeowners association over the fence, which case was eventually settled with the entry of mutual restraining orders and an agreement by the Plotniks to move their fence back three feet from the property line. The agreement contained a standard attorney’s fees provision contained in most settlement agreements.
However, this was only the beginning of misery for the Plotniks. They claimed that Meihaus dumped his yard clippings in the three foot corridor between the Plotniks’ fence and the common boundary line, made obscene gestures to the Plotniks and their children, damaged their trees and the fence, and engaged in various acts of intimidation directed towards them and their family members.
One day, David Plotnik heard banging on the fence and he went out, with camera in hand, to investigate the noise and to photograph the offending yard clippings. While he did so, the Plotniks’ 12″ miniature pinscher, “Romeo”, escaped and made his way into Meihaus’s yard. When Plotnik had made his way around the house and over to the Meihaus residence, he arrived just in time to see Romeo roll across the yard, through a gate, and hit a tree in the Plotnik yard. Plotnik immediately entered Meihaus’s yard and saw Meihaus returning to his house with a baseball bat in hand. When Plotnik confronted Meihaus about why he had attacked Romeo, Meihaus denied having struck the dog and claimed that he had only used the bat to “guide” Romeo back to the Plotniks’ property.
The Trial
The Plotniks sued Meihaus under an assortment of legal theories, including trespass to personal property and negligence. The jury awarded the Plotniks monetary damages for their costs incurred for Romeo’s surgery and post-operative care, and for the emotional distress that each of them suffered as a result of the baseball bat incident.
Meihaus appealed the verdict, arguing that he had lawfully exercised his right to self-defense. The Court of Appeal rejected that argument stating that the jury’s findings that he had not acted in self-defense could not be disturbed.
More importantly, Meihaus argued that a pet owner could not recover monetary damages for emotional distress suffered as a result of injuries caused to the pet. All pet owners will be pleased to know that the Court of Appeal disagreed.
The Court of Appeal’s Decision
The Court of Appeals denied recovery under a negligence theory. It ruled, however, that a dog is an item of personal property to its owner and that Romeo’s owner could clearly recover the economic, or out-of-pocket, losses attributable to the dog’s surgery and post-operative care under a trespass to chattels theory. The real question was whether emotional distress damages were also recoverable.
The Court found no California cases which stated that emotional distress damages were not recoverable and it agreed with published decisions from other states which awarded damages for a pet owner’s emotional distress. It quoted with approval from the case of LaPorte v. Associated Independents, Inc. (Fla. 1964) 163 So.2nd 267, 269: “The affection of a master for his dog is a very real thing and … the malicious destruction of the pet provides an element of damage for which the owner should recover, irrespective of the value of the animal…”
Quoting favorably from a very old California case (Johnson v. McConnell (1889) 80 Cal. 545, at 549), the Court noted: “While it has been said that [dogs] have nearly always been held ‘to be entitled to less regard and protection than more harmless domestic animals,’ it is equally true that there are no other domestic animals to which the owner or his family can become more strongly attached, or the loss of which will be more keenly felt.”
Meihaus’s Ultimate Comeuppance
In what to most pet-owning lawyers would seem to be the most ironic, yet deserving, comeuppance received by Meihuas for having applied his Louisville Slugger
to Romeo’s hindquarters is that the Plotiniks were awarded $93,780 in attorney’s fees. The appellate court found that Meihaus’s conduct violated the terms of the restraining orders which were provided in the original settlement agreement. As such, on a breach of contract theory, the court found a basis to affirm the trial court’s award to the Plotniks of their attorney’s fees expense incurred during the trial.
What Does The Plotnik Decision Mean?
The Plotnik case now makes clear that, in California, a pet owner may recover monetary damages for the emotional distress which the owner suffers as a result of the intentional conduct of a third party in killing or injuring the pet. The decision is limited to cases involving intentionally wrongful conduct and does not apply to cases where the animal is injured through the mere negligence of the third party.
This is something that most pet owners would intrinsically seem to know in their hearts is right or fair; it only took a while for the courts in California to find a case with the right facts to allow the law to be firmly enunciated.
]]>In an era when development costs have skyrocketed, while development money is scarce and investors leery, the financial risks of the development process make it imperative that the design professional be cautious about allowing the development client to incur too large of an account receivable. And it behooves the design professional to become familiar with the design professional lien.
Which Design Professionals Have Lien Rights?
For over twenty years, California law has defined a “design professional” as an architect, an engineer, or a land surveyor. However, the Civil Code’s treatment of construction lien rights was overhauled effective July 1, 2012, and landscape architects were added to the class of design professionals who have lien rights. Civil Code Section 8014.
The design professional must have a written contract for his or her services, and that contract must be with the landowner. Importantly, the landowner with whom the contract is created must also be the landowner at the time that the design professional’s claim of lien is recorded. The contract has to be for the design, engineering, or planning of a work of improvement. General consulting services will not typically give rise to lien rights for the design professional.
In preparing the written services contract, the design professional should always check to see just who the landowner is. Often, it will be an entity, which entity could be different than the entity which is undertaking the development process. The contract should also specify the work of improvement for which the services are being provided.
The Prerequisites
In order to use the design professional lien, construction on the project may not have begun yet. On the other hand, a design professional lien may not be recorded unless the landowner has already obtained a building permit or other governmental approval in furtherance of the project. Civil Code Section 8302(c). Thus, if a permit or other governmental approval is not obtained by the developer-owner, then the design professional has no lien rights.
The lien is available for the amount of the fee which has been provided under the contract or the reasonable value of the services, whichever is less. Inevitably, in a fee dispute with an owner, this may lead to a critical examination of the reasonableness of the design professional’s fees. Thus, it is important that the design professional maintain detailed records on how their time was spent on the project so that the design fees may be justified.
The landowner must have actually defaulted in the payment of the professional fees required by the contract or must have refused to pay the design professional’s demand for fees owed under the contract. And, not less than ten days before the claim of lien is recorded, the design professional must give the landowner-client a written notice which demands payment and states that a default has occurred under the contract and the amount of that default. Civil Code Section 8304(c).
The design professional must record a lien within ninety days of knowing, or having reason to know, that the project will not be started. Civil Code Section 8312.
One important limitation exists on the use of a design professional lien: A design professional cannot obtain a lien for services provided for a work of improvement relating to a single-family, owner-occupied residence for which the expected construction cost is less than $100,000.
What Must Be Included In The Lien?
A construction lien, which has its origins in the California Constitution (Article XIV, Section 3), has long been viewed as an extraordinarily powerful remedy for the contractor, or, in this case, the design professional, because it provides a form of security for payment of the design fees. Therefore, the courts have required that the lien claimant comply with the statutory requirements.
The design professional’s claim of lien must contain the following information:
1. The name of the design professional.
2. The dollar amount of the claim.
3. The current owner of record of the project site.
4. The legal description of the site.
5. An identification of the building permit or other governmental approval given for the work of improvement.
The legal description often crops up at the last moment as something that the lien claimant has difficulty in locating. Many County Recorder’s offices have copies of deeds available online; however, if the design professional has a good working relationship with a title company, a copy of the deed can often be obtained with a quick telephone call.
Because of the frequency with which they use lien claims, some design professionals have office procedures in place to accurately gather the information needed to prepare the lien and they use a template to create the lien form itself. Yet, with the importance of complying with the statutory requirements for the claim of lien, it may also be worth considering having an attorney prepare the claim of lien.
How Long Does The Lien Remain Valid?
The act of recording the lien is what imposes the lien on the property. However, the lien is not indefinitely valid; it will automatically expire if either (1) the project construction begins or (2) a lawsuit seeking to enforce the lien is not filed within ninety (90) days of the date the lien was recorded.
The design professional is presented with a bit of a quandary if the lien is recorded shortly before construction is anticipated to begin. Lien claimants often like to record a lien and then negotiate with the landowner, hoping that the lien will exert pressure upon the landowner by complicating the process of obtaining the necessary construction financing. However, if construction is close to beginning, the financing is most likely already in place. The design professional can prevent the lien from expiring by filing a lawsuit to enforce the lien, but the lien claimant usually wants to avoid the legal fees and court costs associated with starting up a lawsuit.
So, what is the design professional to do under such circumstances? If the design professional lien has expired because construction of the project for which the professional provided services has already begun, then the design professional lien may be converted into a mechanic’s lien if all of the following requirements are met:
1. The design professional lien remains fully or partially unpaid.
2. Within thirty days after expiration of the design professional lien (only under Civil Code Section 8306(b)(1) where the lien has expired because construction of the project has begun), the design professional records a mechanic’s lien for the amount of the unpaid design professional lien.
3. The mechanic’s lien must state that it is a converted design professional lien but is recorded and is being enforced as a mechanic’s lien.
Where the design professional lien is converted to a mechanic’s lien, the design professional does not need to provide a preliminary notice to enforce the mechanic’s lien.
The design professional’s converted mechanic’s lien is effective as of the date of recording. It is given priority over a lien or other encumbrance on the property on which the project is situated which attaches after the work on the project is started (or was unrecorded at the beginning of the work on the project and of which the design professional had no notice).
However, this issue of lien priority can pose a problem for the design professional if other liens have attached between the time that the design professional’s original lien was recorded and the date that the converted mechanic’s lien was recorded. The converted mechanic’s lien will be junior to such intervening liens. Perhaps the best advice for the design professional is, when it may be reasonably expected that other liens may attach to the property before the design professional’s converted mechanic’s lien can be recorded, to move forward with an action to enforce the original design professional lien while it is still viable.
It should be noted that, where a design professional lien has expired because the design professional failed to file an enforcement lawsuit within ninety days, that expired lien cannot be converted in this manner.
If the landowner satisfies or partially satisfies the lien, the design professional must then execute and record a document that demonstrates the partial or full satisfaction of the lien amount and releases so much of the lien as is appropriate.
Having A System Helps
The design professional has a very powerful weapon in the design professional lien for gaining payment from a defaulting developer. While the statutory requirements for asserting such a lien must be adhered to, they are not terribly complex and vigilance by the design professional will usually serve to protect the viability of the lien as an option for payment.
Often, where a landowner has stopped paying the design fees, the design professional withdraws from further service under the contract and may no longer be privy to the developer’s actions or plans for the project. In such an instance, the design professional should establish an office system which monitors when the landowner obtains a building permit or other approval for the project because that is the event which triggers the right of the design professional to record a lien. This might consist of having a staff member make a weekly call to the local building department, or, where the city or county maintains online information about issuing building permits, making frequent checks of the city’s or county’s website.
The design professional also should not delay for long in asserting his or her lien rights once the building permit has been issued because construction can begin with little prior fanfare. Asserting lien rights early in the development process will give the design professional priority over other subsequent lien claimants. If, however, the design professional lien has been lost due to the commencement of construction activities, the design professional should not lose heart as a mechanic’s lien will usually still be available to the professional under Civil Code Section 8400.
]]>If you have ultimately decided that you want to have a will, your next step is to make an appointment with an estate planning attorney to help you design an estate plan that is suitable for your needs and circumstances.
But, before you reach for the phone to make that call, a little planning of your own will make the meeting more efficient (and probably less costly).
A Little More Conversation
Having a frank discussion with your spouse about your overall estate planning objectives is a good idea. Spouses needn’t be in agreement on everything because each spouse can make different provisions in his or her separate will. However, having some basic understanding and agreement on the major concepts will make the job easier for all concerned.
Some fundamental questions should be considered before meeting with an attorney:
1. What is your basic desire for the distribution of your estate? Most clients intend to benefit their children, if they have any, but you can also consider making bequests to friends, other family members, charitable gifts, or a combination of any of them.
2. If you have children, do you wish for them to share equally in your estate or do you have reasons to treat them differently? You have no obligation to treat your children equally, although, more often than not, that is how parents choose to treat their children (often from the fear of appearing to favor one child over another). Yet, some children may have greater needs than others, particularly if they are grown and you already have been able to develop some sense as to the career or financial path on which each child’s life seems to be taking them. One child could have medical issues where he needs a greater portion of your estate to pay for their medical expenses. Or, where there is a disparity in age between the eldest and youngest, you may wish to have more funds available to pay for the youngest child’s education.
3. If your children are not old enough to inherit your estate yet, do you have someone whom you would like to manage those monies for their benefit until they are old enough to receive them? (Monies can be set aside in a trust or in a custodianship until the children reach an age where they can be responsible enough to manage their own money. Or, if not placed in a trust or custodianship, a guardian of the child’s estate can be appointed by the court to manage the inheritance until the child becomes an adult. Trusts, custodianships and guardianships are outside the scope of this post and will have to be the subject of a future article.) In any case, you will need to select someone who can manage those funds until the child(ren) is/are older. That person can be another family member, a friend, or a professional fiduciary.
4. If your children are adults with children of their own, do you wish to benefit your grandchildren with direct gifts to them? Or do you prefer to leave your estate to your children and allow them to make the decisions about how to benefit your grandchildren? The former approach makes certain that the grandchildren receive a specific gift whereas the latter approach builds in greater flexibility for your children, yet is reliant upon your children passing along some of their own inheritance to your grandchildren.
5. If you want to benefit a charity with some or all of your assets, which charitable organization do you wish to benefit with that gift? Is your gift-giving faith based? Is it designed to fund medical research or some other work that will improve the world for future generations? Do you want to benefit a national charity, or do you prefer to be charitable closer to home in your own community? There are no right or wrong answers as most any charity would stand to benefit from a cash bequest. But, in selecting a charity, choose the one whose programs and ideals are most consistent with your own.
Just What Do You Own?
It is easy to think that, if asked, you can quickly list out all of the assets that you own. But, after a meeting with your attorney in which many new concepts may have been introduced to you, it can be easy to overlook an asset or two. So, while you have some free time before your meeting, pencil out a list of all of your assets. Be sure to include all real estate, any securities or other investments, any partnership or limited liability company interests, any business(es) which you may own, any promissory notes or other debts owed to you, bank accounts, cars, valuable antiques and jewelry, and cash.
It is important for the attorney to gain an understanding of the net value of your estate to determine what type of estate plan will be best suited for your needs. With the “fiscal cliff deal” reached between Congress, in 2013, each person can now transfer a combined total of $5.25 million during their lifetime (by gift) and at death. Therefore, knowing the amount of the equity (fair market value less any debt) in each of your assets will assist the attorney in assessing whether your estate needs a more sophisticated plan to avoid estate taxes, or, because your estate is small enough that it is unlikely to be taxed at your death, your estate’s gift-giving plan can be designed without any regard to taxes.
Be Well Represented
If your estate plan does not utilize a trust, it is quite possible that your estate will need to be probated. In the probate process, an individual (known as the “personal representative” or “executor”) is charged with the responsibility of managing that process. You should give thought to whom you would select for that task. Many clients nominate one of their children, but it can also be a trusted friend, or a professional fiduciary. Whomever you select, it should be someone who has reasonable arithmetic skills and who is accustomed to (or at least not intimidated by) working with an attorney.
If you have minor children, you should give thought to whom to nominate to serve as their guardian should you die before they become adults. There should be a guardian of their person and a guardian of their estate. The guardian of their person will most likely be the person with whom the children will live, while the guardian of their estate would be the person charged with managing their finances while they remain a minor. These positions can be filled by the same individual, or you can nominate different persons to serve in each capacity.
Burial Plans
You will assist your family by clearly stating any preferences which you may have regarding your desires for the disposition of your remains upon death. If you would like to be cremated, that should be stated in your will, along with any special instructions as to what you would like done with your ashes. If you have any prepaid burial arrangements, you should provide a copy of the contract to the lawyer.
What To Take With You To The Appointment
You will expedite the process of preparing your estate planning documents if you take the documents describing your assets to the initial meeting with your attorney. He or she will need to see how the assets are currently titled and verify the values of any financial assets. So, be certain to take copies of documents such as deeds and appraisals to any real property, the most recent mortgage statement showing the amount of the outstanding debt, the trust deeds securing that debt, the most recent statement for any brokerage, money market, or bank accounts, copies of any promissory notes owed to you and any trust deeds which might secure the notes, copies of any partnership agreements or limited liability company operating agreements, leases, and automobile certificates of title (“pink slips”). If you have any other loans, be certain to take the note or other loan documents.
Where There’s A Will
If you are still a part of the 55% of Americans who don’t have a will, and you are tired of waking up during the night and worrying about what kind of mess you will leave behind for your family if you die without one, take that simple step of contacting an attorney to have one prepared for you.
Having a will professionally prepared is generally not a terribly difficult process. If your attorney advises that you use a simple will, the cost will also be surprisingly affordable. Incorporating trusts and other more sophisticated forms of estate planning can increase the cost, but they can also make the lives of your loved ones much easier after you are gone, and they can often save your estate from substantial estate taxes or probate costs.
Please feel free to give us a call if we can assist you in completing this important estate planning process.
]]>Have you awakened during the night and worried about the fact that you don’t have a will yet? If so, you are not alone. A study conducted a few years ago found that 55% of all adult Americans do not have a will. Apparently, misery still loves company.
Do I Really Need A Will?
Why do you even need to have a will? Contrary to what many people believe — that, if you don’t have a will, your property will automatically be transferred (“escheat”) at your death to the State (what sounds like it would probably be a good idea right now to help balance California’s upside down budget) — in most cases, your property will simply be transferred to your family members. But, it may not be the family members that you want to benefit from your property. Or it may not be in the percentages that you desire. Or maybe you don’t want everyone in your family to share in your estate, preferring instead to leave it to one or two special family members.
What Is A Will?
A will is simply a legally enforceable directive that you create which states how your property is to be distributed at the time of your death. You can specify that family members or friends will benefit from your property at your death. Or, you can forego giving anything to family or friends and give all of your estate to your church, the ASPCA (American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals), or some other charitable organization.
In your will, you can create a laundry list of specific bequests by which you parse out every pot and pan, or other piece of personal property, to a lengthy list of recipients. Or you can simply state that you leave your entire estate to one or more individuals. Or any combination of these two types of bequests. The types of provisions to bequeath your property are only limited by your imagination.
And a will can be more than merely a directive for the distribution of your property at death. It can be used to nominate someone to serve as the guardian of your underage children in the event that you should die before your children become adults. Or it can be used to state whether you want special burial arrangements or, perhaps, that you wish to be cremated.
A Perhaps Ill-Advised Use of Your Will
A will can even be used to diss that family member that you never had the courage to tell off during your lifetime. Really! Most good lawyers will usually discourage a client from using a will to do that, but it can certainly be done. Imagine something like this: “I intentionally fail to make any provision for my daughter, Lucy, for the reason that she has completely ignored me since she completed her college studies at my expense. So, Lucy, while your brother and sister each enjoy their millions of dollars in inheritance, think about all of the times that you could have visited me in the nursing home, but didn’t do so.”
A standard disinheritance clause does the same thing yet doesn’t make you look quite so petty after your death.
Can My Spouse And I Save Money and Create a Joint Will?
I can’t recall a single occasion in which I have recommended to a married couple that they create a joint will. I think that most of my professional colleagues would usually agree. Doing so can raise the suggestion that there was a contract made between the spouses to make specific reciprocal provisions in their wills which can lead to litigation if one spouse decides to later create a separate will with different provisions that don’t benefit the other spouse.
Separate wills also permit spouses to address the different issues or circumstances that they may each have, such as dealing with children from a prior marriage, or the distribution of a spouse’s separate property.
And simple wills are usually sufficiently inexpensive that there isn’t much of a cost savings if a couple were to create a joint will.
Who Handles Your Probate?
If you use a simple will to provide for the distribution of your estate, chances are good that your will will have to be probated. (The advantages of avoiding probate, and how to do it, will have to be the subject of a future article.) In your will, you can nominate the person whom you would like to manage the probate administration process on your behalf. That person is called an “executor”, or a “personal representative”. You can nominate your child, another family member, a friend, or, if you have a sizeable estate, you can nominate the trust department of your bank. And, if you fail to nominate anyone, the probate court can appoint anyone who seeks the appointment, or even the local county’s Public Administrator.
Do I Really Need An Attorney to Prepare My Will?
Does an attorney have to prepare my will? In a word, “no.” But, I also don’t recommend that you extract a decayed tooth by yourself or that you stitch up a deep wound on your own. Sometimes, it makes sense to consult with a professional and have him or her do the work for you.
Many stationery stores sell a preprinted will in which you fill in the blanks. Or you can buy a package of legal documents from one of O.J. Simpson’s criminal defense attorneys who advertises them on television. However, in California, if a will is not formally witnessed, there are strict rules about mixing handwritten provisions with preprinted language in a will. Is it worth it to risk having your will later be determined to be invalid just to save a few hundred dollars? Such a result would completely frustrate your testamentary intentions.
And an experienced estate planner will most likely provide you with options that you didn’t even know were available to you. In most cases, a professional will earn their keep.
Most everyone will benefit from having a will. They tend to discourage arguments between family members after you are gone and they make certain that your property will be given to just the right person(s) upon your death. Simple wills are usually very modestly priced (as compared with more sophisticated forms of estate plans). Do your family a favor and make an appointment today with an experienced estate planning attorney to discuss creating a personalized estate plan.
In the next installment, we will examine what types of issues you will need to consider before you pay a visit to your estate planning attorney to prepare your will.
]]>Real estate agents play a vital role in the real estate industry as they interface between sellers and buyers. Among other things, they assist sellers in making a home attractive for potential buyers and they offer their expertise in helping a seller determine an appropriate listing price. They also assist buyers in determining what the buyer really needs in a residence and what the buyer can realistically afford.
The Agent’s Duty To Disclose
One of the most important services that an agent can provide to a buyer, and particularly an inexperienced one, is to assist the buyer in evaluating a property’s condition so that the buyer does not buy a house which has numerous mechanical or structural surprises that will cost the buyer more than was expected to make the house livable.
In adopting Civil Code Section 2079, the California legislature recognized the importance of the agent’s experience and knowledge by requiring the agent to conduct a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of a property offered for sale and to disclose to the prospective purchaser all facts materially affecting the value or desirability of the property that an investigation would reveal. The real estate agent satisfies much of that duty through the use of the Transfer Disclosure Statement (TDS), a form which the seller and both the seller’s and buyer’s agents complete and provide to a buyer during the escrow.
But, the agent’s duty doesn’t end with his or her signature on the TDS. The law imposes a more far-reaching duty of disclosure on an agent than merely completing the TDS form, which only requires that they disclose facts and conditions which would be revealed by a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection. California law requires an agent to actively try to learn material facts that the agent does not know that might affect their client in making a decision to buy a property.
The Agent Has To Dig To Learn Information
In Field v. Century 21 Klowden-Forness Realty (1998) 63 Cal.App.4th 18, the Court of Appeals (Fourth District) said that an agent must place herself in the buyer’s position and to ask herself what type of information the buyer would need to know in order to make a well-informed buying decision. Then, the agent must investigate facts which are not known to the agent and disclose to the buyer all material facts that might reasonably be discovered.
I tried a case some years ago in which an agent sold a property to buyers which appeared to them (and any reasonable person) to be a duplex. Each of the units had separate kitchen facilities and each was accessed through a separate entrance. The buyers had informed the agent that they intended to use the property as a duplex for their respective families. The agent knew that there were many illegally-created duplexes in the area where this property was located, but he never took it upon himself to investigate with the local planning and building officials whether or not this particular duplex had been legally created.
At trial, the agent testified that he had no actual knowledge that the duplex had not been legally created and sought to defend himself on the basis that he only needed to disclose the information that he actually knew.
The jury was given a contrary instruction, however, based upon the Field v. Century 21 Klowden-Forness Realty case, because the agent should have considered that, even though the agent didn’t have information that the duplex was illegally created, the legal status of the duplex was an important fact which the buyers needed to know to make an informed decision about buying that property. In returning a verdict against the agent, the jury found that he should have actively researched that information with local officials in order to properly inform his buyers.
A Buyer’s Failure To Investigate Does Not Absolve The Agent
The agent in my case also argued at trial that the buyers should have called the local building officials themselves to determine the legal status of the duplex property. However, a real estate agent, who owes a fiduciary duty to his or her client, and who usually has a superior knowledge about purchasing real estate over that of his client, cannot legally shift responsibility to the client to undertake that investigation. California law provides that the client has a right to rely upon the agent and that it is no defense that the buyer failed to exercise reasonable care to protect his or her own interests, or that the client might have learned the true facts by independently investigating the circumstances of the representations himself. Schoenberg v. Romike Properties (1967) 251 Cal.App.2d 154, 162; Sime v. Malouf (1949) 95 Cal.App.2d 82.
Agents Beware!
Most real estate agents are surprised to learn that they have an obligation to disclose to their client more information than they actually know and that they have to undertake an affirmative investigation of those facts which might be important for a buyer to know in deciding whether or not to purchase property. But, that is California law.
The extent of the agent’s affirmative duty to investigate and disclose facts to their client is not limitless. It depends upon the facts of the transaction and the buyer’s knowledge and experience, the questions asked by the buyer, and the nature of the property and terms of the sale.
What Are The Agent And Buyer To Do?
Diligent real estate agents should conduct an extensive discussion with their buyer to learn exactly how the buyer intends to use the property so that the agent will be better able to anticipate the information which would be important for the client to know to make the purchase decision. And, then, the agent should actually spend some time trying to think through the various issues which the specific property might possibly raise for the buyer’s anticipated use.
Similarly, an astute buyer should make certain that he or she has fully discussed with the agent how the property will be used, or what the buyer’s expectations are for the property. If the buyer has any unusual needs for the property, or if there is any expectation which is not customary in a garden variety residential purchase, the buyer should be certain to ask the agent about those issues so as to place the agent on notice that the information is important in the buyer’s purchase decision.
There is nothing worse than a real estate transaction that has gone bad. The buyer is unhappy because their dream home has become a nightmare. The seller is usually accused of having concealed information from the buyer, and the agents, who are the fiduciaries of their clients, are almost invariably made to refund some or all of their commissions to the clients. Worse yet, the seller and agents could get sued. The professional agent can avoid that, both for the agent’s sake and that of his buyer-client, by taking some time during the transaction to thoroughly investigate all of the facts about the property.
]]>Right now, at perhaps the worst possible moment for you, your right to pursue a personal injury claim for the injuries you have sustained could be in serious danger. You are about to be put through a series of different people questioning you about the collision and the injuries which you may have suffered, whether it is the other driver, other motorists who may have stopped, the investigating police officer, or, eventually, the other driver’s insurance claims adjuster. And the statements that you make to any of them could cause serious damage to your case.
Your Injuries May Not Be Immediately Apparent
Because of the physical forces that are involved in car crashes, by far, the most common injury that motorists sustain are soft tissue injuries – strains of ligaments, tendons and connective tissue, usually of the neck and back. Physicians and physical therapists will almost universally agree that you may have experienced one of these soft tissue injuries in the crash, yet you feel nothing at the scene of the accident. It may be only during that night, or the next day or two, that your neck or back begins to stiffen and you begin to feel the pain. Yet, you have everyone, first at the accident scene, and then later, pressing you for the details of your injuries.
At the collision site, even if you don’t then feel any aches or pains, you should never adopt an unequivocal stance that you have not been hurt. Doing so will only serve to cast some doubt at trial about the validity or severity of your injury claim if you later do begin to experience pain. Instead, you should politely thank the motorists for stopping, but you don’t need to answer their inquiries about the nature or severity of any possible injuries.
And, when approached by the other driver (who caused the collision) who wants to talk with you about the collision, resist the urge to engage in argument. It wins you nothing to do so, and later, at trial, hearing the other driver describe to the jurors that nasty conversation will cause you much embarrassment and can give the jury the idea that you are a bully or a hothead. And that’s not good for your case.
Do You Talk To The Investigating Police Officer?
Where an accident involves bodily injury to any driver or passenger, law enforcement officers will conduct an accident investigation and later prepare an investigation report. As a part of their investigation, the police will want to talk with you since you may be the best witness to the collision and its causes. Should you answer the officer’s questions? Yes, answer honestly. However, your answers should be concise and you should only answer the specific question asked. And, do not under any circumstance admit any fault in causing the accident. Fault is something that judges and juries decide – not you, who has just been shaken up in a collision and who doesn’t yet have a full picture of the entire incident.
And, importantly, do not unequivocally deny to the officer that you suffered any injury. Instead, when the officer asks if you were injured, if you don’t yet feel any aches or pains, you simply tell the officer that it is too early for you to say for sure. Then, leave it at that.
“May I Record Your Statement?”
After the collision, the other driver will report the crash to his or her insurance company. The insurer will then assign the claim to one of its adjusters. Understand a very important concept: The job of that adjuster is to protect the company’s money. It is not to try to help you.
The adjuster may well call you at home or work to ask you about the details of the collision or your injuries. The adjuster will quite likely even ask to record your statement about the crash. Don’t. Just don’t. Fight your natural tendency to be helpful. You have absolutely no obligation to submit to the adjuster’s interview. And, trust me, the interview which you provide the adjuster will not be so convincing that the adjuster will want to immediately write you a check for your medical bills and provide you a rental car. That interview will be used for the purpose of trying to see if you will make an admission about the cause of the collision or about your injuries that can be used against you later on during an arbitration or trial of your injury claim. You should graciously decline the request to be interviewed and advise the adjuster that your attorney will contact her to discuss the claim.
If you do submit to such an interview, and you unwittingly make a statement which suggests that your own driving may have been a cause of the collision, or that you weren’t really significantly injured, you have just harmed your case. You will hear that statement (called an “admission”) repeated to you during your deposition, and later during your trial or arbitration.
I recommend to my clients that they allow me, as their attorney, to talk with the insurance adjuster. An experienced personal injury attorney knows how to give the adjuster the information that he or she needs to do her job in establishing the appropriate monetary reserves for the case, but which steers clear of making statements that can harm your case.
Once your lawsuit is filed, almost invariably, the defense attorney will ask to take your deposition. (A deposition is an opportunity for the lawyer to ask you questions about the accident and your injuries while you are under oath.) The transcript of the deposition will be used at trial by the insurance company’s attorney to try to show the jury that you are confused in your recollection of the events, or, worse yet, that you are not telling the truth. Under most circumstances, you must submit to a deposition. But, you will be accompanied to the deposition by your attorney who can raise appropriate objections to questions, or even instruct you to not answer certain inappropriate questions, if the circumstances warrant it. In other words, there is some degree of protection for you in that process.
So, if the insurance defense lawyer will always have the chance to ask you questions during a deposition, then why should you create an additional opportunity for possible misstatements by your providing the adjuster a recorded interview shortly after the collision? That’s right; you shouldn’t. Instead, opt to remain silent.
What You Should and Shouldn’t Do
In short, if involved in a collision, you need not, and should not, talk with other motorists, or the other driver, about what caused the collision or whether or not you have been injured. You should talk with the investigating officer about the events of the crash, and, if you can already feel that you have been injured, tell the officer that. But, if you don’t feel injured, do not deny to the officer that you were injured in the collision. Instead, simply tell the officer that you are not sure whether or not you were injured.
A Last Thought …
Finally, one last tip about what to do after an auto accident. Most people carry a smart phone that is equipped with a camera which can take still photos or video. If you are physically able to do so, right there at the scene of the accident before the wreckers arrive and move the cars from where they came to rest, use your smart phone to photograph or video the cars involved in the crash. Be sure to capture the location of all of the cars, particularly with respect to each other. Photograph or video the crush damage done to either vehicle. And, if you can do so without causing an incident, be sure to get the other driver in some of the photos or video. Those photographs or videos can be like gold for the attorney who will eventually handle your case.
Now, drive carefully because I am out there sharing the roads with you!
]]>Often, such clients will ask to nominate several or all of their children as co-trustees. Almost invariably, I discourage them from doing that. While I also don’t wish to see any distrust or dissension among siblings after the parents are gone, there are problems that creating co-trustees or other co-fiduciaries can create.
Inconvenience
Often, when dealing with a bank, or while undertaking some other financial transaction or sale of real property on behalf of the trust, the bank or escrow will want to have all of the trustees sign the transaction documents. Where the children who are co-trustees live in different states, this can lead to delays and inconvenience in having to circulate the documents among all of the children for their signatures.
Confusion and Possible Litigation
More importantly, however, having co-trustees can lead to confusion. For example, when dealing with third parties, those third parties can never be sure if they need only deal with one of the co-fiduciaries, or if they need to have both of their agreement. And where two co-trustees cannot agree on whether to take a proposed course of action, that may lead to litigation in the probate court to try to obtain court approval for the intended action, or to prevent the other trustee from taking the proposed action.
Liability for a Co-Fiduciary’s Fraudulent Conduct
Worse yet, the breach of fiduciary duties by one of the trustees can be imputed under some circumstances to the other trustee, which can create serious legal consequences for the innocent trustee.
I am familiar with a current probate administration in Southern California where the decedents named two of their children to be co-executors. During the course of the estate’s administration, the daughter, who worked for some accountants and was thought to have greater financial experience, handled most of the estate’s affairs while the son stood back and allowed her to do so. Unfortunately for the son, however, during the months that the estate’s administration was being handled by the daughter, and unbeknownst to the son, the daughter misappropriated substantial amounts of money from the probate estate’s accounts. Many creditors, including taxing agencies, were not being paid. Moreover, in the midst of the estate’s administration, the daughter quit her position as co-executor and moved to a distant location. She refused to communicate with her brother to transmit to him even simple documents about the estate’s financial condition.
At the time that the son was required to report to the court on the financial condition of the estate, he had to disclose that his sister had misappropriated the estate’s monies. The court then surcharged both the sister and the brother over $140,000, which requires them to repay the estate the stolen funds so that the creditors can be paid off and to permit a distribution of the remaining assets to the other beneficiaries. Applying California Probate Code Section 9631(b)(2), the court reasoned that the brother had improperly delegated the administration of the estate to his co-executor sister. The court didn’t care that the brother had received none of the monies misappropriated from the estate by his sister. They were both liable as co-executors.
I surmise that the court’s decision in that case has now created some real dissension between these siblings, something that the parents probably wanted to avoid and what they could never have conceived with their decision to make their children co-executors.
What Parents Should Do
So, what should parents of multiple children do in nominating an executor or trustee in their estate plan? They should select the child that they believe will do the best job in serving as the fiduciary, whether as an executor or as a trustee. A fiduciary needn’t have any special fiduciary training; however, I do recommend to my clients that they consider naming the child who is most accustomed to working under rules and regulations, or the child who is accustomed to maintaining books of account in their professional or personal life. And, if there is any question about a child’s honesty or integrity, or if a child is having serious financial troubles of his own, then that child should usually always be avoided.
And, then the parents should talk with their children and tell their children that they have made a decision to select the one child as the fiduciary and to give that child their vote of confidence to the other children. If the parents truly believe that naming one child as the fiduciary will create dissension with the other siblings, then the parents should consider naming another family member or a friend. Or perhaps their trusted accountant. Or they can name a private professional fiduciary or a bank’s trust department as the fiduciary.
While the parents’ concerns about maintaining sibling harmony after their own deaths is admirable, those parents should consider other alternatives instead of naming two or more of their children co-fiduciaries because that can be a recipe for a real disaster.
]]>Knowing when to stop trying to accommodate the tenants’ excuses and to start up an eviction process is something that is different for each landlord and can often depend upon the landlord’s own debt service obligations for their rental property.
Treat A Rental Property Like A Business
We recommend to our clients to view a rental property like they would any other business. If a merchant were to allow customers to take goods from their store without having to pay for them, that merchant wouldn’t be able to remain in business for very long. The same is true for the landlord where the tenants aren’t paying their rent. The landlord should ask herself the question, “How long can I afford to not have the tenant pay rent and still be able to pay the mortgage on the property?”
Eviction
When the landlord eventually concludes that the tenants can no longer remain in the property, the landlord does have some options. One is to begin an unlawful detainer proceeding by serving the tenants with a three-day notice to pay rent. A three-day notice is a legal prerequisite for filing an unlawful detainer action to regain possession of the property from the tenants.
Often, the tenants won’t understand that the landlord is serious about their need to pay rent unless and until a three-day notice is actually served upon them. However, while an unlawful detainer action is often a necessary step for a landlord to regain possession of their rental property from the tenants, it can also be an expensive proposition, particularly if the tenants are savvy and know how to prolong the process and make it more costly for the landlord.
“Cash for Keys”
Another option available to a landlord is to offer the tenants some “cash for keys.” That is to say, the landlord offers to pay the tenants to move out of their house. This may seem like an extraordinary step — having to pay a defaulting tenant to give up possession of the landlord’s rental property — but, with the cost of a lengthy eviction often reaching thousands of dollars, it can also often result in an actual savings of money for the landlord. And, when a tenant has defaulted in their payment of rent for a month or two, there is usually too little money or other assets against which a landlord could hope to enforce a future judgment for those unpaid rents. So, the landlord is better off quickly regaining possession of their rental unit so that they can get it cleaned and promptly re-rented.
The “Key Components”
There are several “key” components to such a “cash for keys” arrangement, however. First, the amount of money that the landlord offers the tenants for the keys to the house should be reasonable. Depending upon the amount of the monthly rent, perhaps an amount equal to a week’s or two weeks’ rent. But, this is all negotiable between the landlord and the tenants and, while the landlord should be reasonable, he should not feel a need to be generous or benevolent. After all, if the landlord offers to pay too much cash, she doesn’t really save much more than if she had actually gone through the eviction process.
Second, the landlord should rarely give the tenants the “cash for keys” money until the tenant has actually entirely moved out. Third, the tenants should be given enough time to pack up their belongings and move from the house. Often, this may require one to two weeks’ time. The tenants, however, will usually want a longer period of time. They are getting free rent and know that, when they move elsewhere, they will have to pay the first month’s rent and a security deposit, which they may not have. But, there needs to be a sense of urgency impressed upon the tenants that they need to get out quickly so that the landlord can get the property back and re-rent it so that it begins to produce income for the landlord again. Almost invariably, the landlord benefits from as short a period of time as possible.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, there needs to be a legally enforceable right for the landlord to have the tenants immediately evicted if the tenants have not moved out by the agreed-upon date. If the landlord has agreed to pay the tenants money to regain possession, and the tenants don’t actually leave by the move-out date, the landlord will have lost precious time if he has to start the eviction process now from scratch. It is far better to have the tenants’ written agreement that, in exchange for the promised “cash for keys”, the tenants are giving up the right to a trial and are giving up possession of the property so that a writ of possession can be obtained and served upon the tenants should they not actually move out.
Preserving this important right for the landlord is usually something that should be entrusted to a lawyer to handle because it does require that specific language be used in the “cash for keys” agreement. An experienced eviction attorney can quickly draft the agreement for the landlord’s use with the tenants and, in doing so, the landlord will usually save quite a bit of cost by avoiding a lengthy unlawful detainer process and trial.
In summary, a landlord should treat the rental property like a business by using good business judgment in your dealings with your tenants. Then, think outside the box and be creative in working out a resolution of the unpaid rent and the need to regain possession of the property. But, most importantly, make sure that the agreement has an enforcement mechanism that will permit the landlord to actually regain possession of the rental house.
]]>